Broiling meat or vegetables can be a tricky business. Even professional chefs struggle sometimes to get it done right.
Of course, there are many technicalities to take care of while broiling your food. Including the right temperature, the right cooking duration, and choosing a good broiler pan.
But what is the best broiler pan?
A broiler pan is one of the most important aspects of broiling food. It is basically a method to cook meat, veggies, poultry, or fish by being exposed to the heat directly. It is quite a useful tool that helps you cook faster and easier.
A broiler pan is designed for broiling and grilling while making sure that the nutrients in your food stay intact. It also drains all the grease and cooking juices from your meat or fish. Ultimately, it allows you to prepare different types of dishes using less oil.
In the past couple of years, broiler manufacturer companies have increased their zeal to create the best broiler pans. You can find multiple broiler pans in the market but it is pretty daunting to choose the right one for you.
If you are looking for a quality broiler pan, you need to put a little more effort into the research. However, we will make it a bit easier for you. We hand-picked some top-notch broiler pans that will help you broil and roast delicious food.
OUR TOP PICK
Farberware is a well-known brand in high-quality kitchen goods. Farberware products are popular for a good reason. If you are looking for a reliable and long-lasting broiler pan within your budget, this one is an ideal option.
This chrome-plated broiler pan will surprise you with its quality. It will also allow you to get more out of your cooking. It is a durable item that even outperforms other products due to its heavy steel surface.
The uniform distribution of heat is a problem with ordinary broiler pans, but this chrome-plated roaster ensures a uniform heat spread. Moreover, you'll not face food sticking at its surface and that makes it easy to clean.
Its dual-riveted cast stainless steel handles are wide enough to make it easier to remove from the oven. On the other hand, the wide handles on its chrome-plated rack make it easier to remove roasts, seafood, and more. It comes with an oven-safe label that makes it withstand a 450F temperature without any damage. You can easily wash it by hand in no time. What else could you wish for?
Pros:
- It has a durable surface.
- Its chrome-plated technology offers uniform heat transmission.
- It has a non-stick coating that makes it easy to clean.
- It can withstand a temperature up to 450°F.
Cons:
- The rotating holds may be dangerous to hold, especially if the pan is hot.
EDITORS CHOICE
Our personal favorite is the Granite Ware Broiler Set that serves a good roasting at home. It is the best broiler pan because it has versatile broiling features. It is compatible with almost every stove.
The item comes with a carbon steel construction to ensure uniform and effective heat distribution. You’ll notice that it will brown better and broil your meal evenly. Furthermore, it comes with a porcelain surface to ensure that nothing sticks to the surface. Therefore, you don't have to put extra effort in cleaning.
The design of this broiling pan is quite attractive and compact, but there are no handles for a firm grip. You have to use kitchen mitts to handle it.
And let’s not forget its amazing oven-safe feature. The dark exterior absorbs the entire oven's energy. Moreover, it is dishwasher safe.
This set comes with 10 pieces; you get 2-different pans; one is for roasting, and the other is for broiling purposes (Dimensions L*W*H: 12.75 x 19.5 x 5.5 inches).
Pros:
- Porcelain natural nonstick surface.
- Excellent heat distribution.
- Offers high durability that takes the performance to a premium level.
- Scratch-resistant.
Cons:
- It doesn’t withstand temperatures beyond 500°F.
- It may leave spots if you use a cooking spray.
BEST VALUE
This broiler pan from Range Kleen doesn’t need any introduction as it is the best choice if you want value for your money.
The quality of this broiler pan is worth mentioning. It is made with a heavy-duty porcelain base and grill to ensure uniform heating. What makes it a popular broiler, is its versatile features and use. It is compatible with a variety of heat sources. These pans are oven-safe up to 1025°F and have OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) quality. It means you can bake and broil anytime and anywhere!
Another interesting thing about this broiler pan is its grill grate that allows fat drippings to drain from the meat. This broiler pan is suitable to use on an outdoor grill and is perfect for broiling fish, meats, and veggies.
And let’s not forget its durability and performance. It is what we can expect from a popular and trusted brand. We strongly recommend this item to those who want to buy a versatile broiler pan for their kitchen.
Pros:
- It comes with multiple cooking equipment.
- Easy to clean, dishwasher safe, and oven-safe to 1025°F.
- Can be used as a baking dish.
- Slightly raised edges keep the ingredients in an evenly set position.
- Durable and versatile use.
Cons:
- Smaller in size.
RUNNER UP
Made of stainless steel, this Norpro stainless steel broil/roast pan set is what every home cook should have in its kitchen. It is designed to give you a professional and durable cooking experience.
Because of its large size, you can cater 2 to 3 servings of your favorite dish with ease, and its perforated top allows the juices or fats to drip down to the bottom surface. It can withstand extremely high oven temperatures.
Another excellent feature of this broiler pan is its equal heat distribution. When you cook anything in this pan, food won’t burn or stick to it immediately.
Pros:
- Its perforated top allows grease and juices to drain while cooking.
- Made of strong, durable stainless steel, this pan fits easily in your oven.
- Easy to clean and use.
- It heats faster and saves you time.
Cons:
- Using the dishwasher is not recommended.
RUNNER UP
Our first runner up is the ProBake Teflon nonstick broil pan from G&S Metal Products Company. This is one of the best broiler pans and allows you to bake, broil, and roast almost all of your favorite food.
This Teflon nonstick broil pan has a broiler rack that helps you cook healthy meals by catching fat drippings on the roasting pan below. This broiler pan comes with a Teflon non-stick coating that keeps your food from sticking to the pan.
This broiler pan comes in a set containing one roasting pan (14.5” x 10.5” x 2”), one baking pan (12.8” x 8.9” x 2”), and a chrome-plated broiler rack with handles. The plus point of the baking pan is that you can also use it for baking cake and brownies.
This bake, broil, and roast set comes with professional-grade steel to ensure uniform and effective heating. This item is coated with Teflon, so we recommend using wooden or silicone utensils.
Pros:
- Uniform heat dissipation.
- Reasonable pricing.
- It includes 3-pans in 1 set and has more value for your money.
- Excellent quality material.
- Easy to use.
Cons:
- It is small in size.
- The coating is not dishwasher safe and may peel off when cleaned accordingly.
RUNNER UP
If you have nailed your cooking skills and want to upgrade to a professional broiler pan, this non-stick Nordic Ware broiler pan is the best choice for you.
If you are searching for a good quality broiler pan to broil meat, veggies, or seafood, then this is the one to fulfill your healthy broiling needs.
This product is made in three layers; a good quality carbon steel material on its surface and the other two layers are made of aluminum. All the layers allow steady heat dissipation and quick heating for a long time. The nonstick coating prevents food from sticking to its surface and is supposed to be dishwasher safe. Although we always recommend washing non-stick pans by hand.
This nonstick broiler set includes a ribbed broiling rack, and a multipurpose drip/baking pan. This 2-piece set is perfect to cook lots of different foods, from broiling poultry to vegetables, or fish, this product is more than enough to meet your needs.
Pros:
- Durable and premium quality material.
- Uniform heat dissipation.
- Reasonable pricing.
- The slightly raised edges keep the ingredients in an evenly set position.
Cons:
- We don’t recommend using a dishwasher and therefore it takes some time to clean this pan.
RUNNER UP
Do you want to cook veggies or meat with some style and confidence? This smart choice broiling pan has an eye-catching design.
This basic broiler pan is made of metallic material to ensure the best performance for a home cook. It makes the pan heat up quickly to prepare food quickly. Moreover, this quality material ensures that the pan is durable and scratch resistant.
This basic broiler pan set contains two pieces; one is the bottom tray, and the other one is the broiler pan. Its bottom tray can be used separately for roasting or baking.
This broiler pan has a non-stick coating that ensures that nothing sticks to the surface of the pan. Moreover, this granite coating is free from harmful chemicals like PFOA and PTFE. All of these features make this broiler pan an ideal choice for every home cook. Furthermore, it is dishwasher safe and oven-safe.
Pros:
- It’s easy to use.
- It is dishwasher safe and oven-safe.
- It comes with a nonstick coating.
- It is durable and resists scratches.
- It takes less baking time and less oil and has a low energy consumption.
Cons:
- Its edges are sensitive and a bit rough.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pans are safe for broiling?
Metallic and steel pans are made of sturdy materials and are an ideal choice for broiling. They’ll last longer and are more heat resistant so they won’t crack.
Is a broiler pan necessary?
Broiler pan helps you broil meat and veggies with less effort. There are several broiler pans available and you have to choose one that can handle extreme heat while broiling. Several broiler pans are oven-safe up to 1000°F. If you are keen on preparing food with less fat in it, a broiling pan is indeed necessary.
Can I broil without a broiler pan?
There are several alternatives to a broiler pan. You can use a baking pan, a roasting pan, or cast-iron as an alternative to a broiler pan.
What is the difference between broiling and baking?
It is basically the heating process that makes broiling different from baking. In broiling, you directly heat the food at extreme temperatures. While in the baking process, you prepare the food while providing heat indirectly and at a low or moderate temperature.
Does broiling make food crispy?
Broiling is all about heating the food at high temperatures. As a result, the food becomes browned and crispy. If you want to enjoy the taste of crispy meals, then you should broil your food.
Conclusion
After going through our list of the best broiler pans, you might have picked up the one that will satisfy your needs. Here is a quick recommendation for those who want to choose from other options:
- The Range Kleen 2-Piece Broiler and Bake Pan is for those who want to broil food at extreme heat. This broiling pan is up to 1025°F oven-safe.
- If you are looking for a multi-purpose broiler pan, then we recommend you to buy the G & S Broiler Pan set.
Let us know in the comments if you have any questions!
